CIVITAI BANNED STABLE DIFFUSION 3

Sebastian Kamph
17 Jun 202404:43

TLDRCivitai has temporarily banned all models based on Stable Diffusion 3 due to licensing concerns. The platform is seeking clarity on the vague legal terms, which may grant the AI too much control over the use of any models trained with SD3 outputs. Despite the ban, users can still access SD3 from Hugging Face and create fine-tuned models elsewhere. The decision aims to protect the community and creators, sparking discussions on the balance between innovation and legal constraints.

Takeaways

  • 🚫 CIVITAI has temporarily banned Stable Diffusion 3 due to licensing concerns.
  • 📜 The ban is based on a lack of clarity in the license associated with Stable Diffusion 3.
  • 🚫 All models and derivatives trained on content created with SD3 outputs are affected by the ban.
  • 🗃️ Existing SD3 models will be archived, making them inaccessible on CIVITAI.
  • 🤔 The move is speculated to be a response to recent issues with the release of Stable Diffusion 3 and Medium 2B, and their licensing terms.
  • 📢 CIVITAI is seeking official clarification from Stability AI regarding the licensing and legal terms.
  • 👩‍⚖️ CIVITAI emphasizes that they are not lawyers and are taking a cautious approach by having a legal team review the license.
  • 🔍 There is a need for an official release from Stability AI to provide further clarity on the licensing issue.
  • 🤷‍♂️ There has been some discussion and misunderstanding about the license's terms, with Stability AI's MC monkey suggesting that it may be misinterpreted.
  • 🎨 Despite the ban, CIVITAI encourages continued experimentation with SD3 if the outputs are of good quality.
  • 🛡️ The decision to ban SD3 is made for the protection of the community and creators, with an apology for any inconvenience caused.
  • 🔄 Users can still access Stable Diffusion 3 from its original release source, Hugging Face, and can make and host fine-tunes elsewhere.

Q & A

  • Why was Stable Diffusion 3 banned on Civitai?

    -Civitai temporarily banned Stable Diffusion 3 due to a lack of clarity in the associated license, which they are currently reviewing for further legal clarity.

  • What does the ban on Stable Diffusion 3 include?

    -The ban includes all models and luras trained on content created with outputs from SD3 based models, as well as utilities such as controll lant. Existing SD3 models will be archived and not accessible.

  • What is the current situation with the licensing of Stable Diffusion 3?

    -The licensing terms have been vague and have caused some controversy. There is a need for official clarification from Stability AI to understand the legal implications better.

  • What is Civitai's stance on the use of AI models with unclear licensing?

    -Civitai is playing it safe by having a legal team review the license to provide further clarity and is not allowing the use of models with unclear licensing in the meantime.

  • How does the ban affect the community and creators on Civitai?

    -The ban is intended to protect the community and creators from potential legal issues arising from the use of SD3. It may cause inconvenience but is seen as a necessary step for safeguarding the platform's integrity.

  • What is the role of Stability AI in this situation?

    -Stability AI is expected to provide official clarification on the licensing terms. Some discussions have taken place, but a definitive statement from Stability AI is awaited.

  • Can users still access Stable Diffusion 3 outside of Civitai?

    -Yes, users can still access Stable Diffusion 3 from Hugging Face where it was initially released, and they can make fine-tunes and host them elsewhere.

  • What is the impact of the ban on the use of SD3 images in data sets?

    -The concern is that the license may grant the AI too much power over the use of not only mods fine-tuned on SD but also on any other models that include S3 images in their data sets.

  • How does the ban reflect on the relationship between Civitai and Stability AI?

    -The ban indicates a cautious approach by Civitai towards the licensing issue, which may put some strain on the relationship until clarity is provided by Stability AI.

  • What is the general sentiment among the community regarding the ban?

    -The community is surprised and is seeking more information and clarification. The ban is seen as a significant move by Civitai and is expected to be a topic of discussion until resolved.

  • What are the implications for future AI models and licensing?

    -The situation highlights the importance of clear licensing for AI models. It may lead to stricter guidelines and more transparent terms for AI model usage in the future.

Outlines

00:00

🚫 Temporary Ban on Stable Diffusion 3 by Civitai

Civitai has announced a temporary ban on all models based on Stable Diffusion 3 (SD3) due to concerns over the license's clarity. This decision affects all models and derivatives trained on SD3 content, including utilities like ControlNet. Existing SD3 models will be archived, making them inaccessible on the platform. The ban is a response to recent controversies surrounding the licensing of SD3, particularly after the release of the model on Medium, which has led to debates over the legal terms. Civitai is seeking official clarification from Stability AI to understand the extent of the AI's power over the use of SD3 and its derivatives. The community is awaiting further information and a final determination on SD3's status on Civitai. Despite the ban, users can still access SD3 from its original release source, Hugging Face, and continue to experiment with fine-tuning and hosting models elsewhere.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Stable Diffusion 3

Stable Diffusion 3 (SD3) is the latest text-to-image generation model developed by Stability AI. It has shown significant improvements in multi-subject prompts, image quality, and spelling capabilities. SD3 utilizes a novel diffusion transformer technology and is designed to handle multimodal inputs, supporting video and 3D functionalities. The model parameters range from 800 million to 8 billion, making it adaptable to various devices. It has been noted for its enhanced text generation capability and improved prompt following, which are crucial for generating high-quality images that align with user prompts. The controversy surrounding SD3's licensing terms has led to concerns within the AI community and has prompted actions such as the temporary ban by CivitAI, as mentioned in the transcript and various articles [^9^] [^11^] [^16^] [^17^].

💡Civitai

Civitai is a major hub for the AI community, particularly known for being a repository of resources related to Stable Diffusion. In response to the licensing concerns surrounding SD3, Civitai has temporarily banned all SD3-based models and any models trained on SD3 outputs. This decision was made to protect the community and avoid potential legal issues, as the license terms for SD3 were seen as granting Stability AI excessive control over the use of models and datasets, as discussed in the provided transcript and articles [^9^] [^11^] [^17^].

💡Licensing Terms

The licensing terms of SD3 have been a point of contention within the AI community. The terms are perceived as restrictive, potentially allowing Stability AI to claim rights over derivative works created using SD3, including models trained on SD3 outputs. This has raised concerns about the future of open-source model development and the ability of creators to build upon existing models without incurring ongoing fees or other restrictions. The ambiguity of these terms led Civitai to ban SD3-related content to protect its community from potential legal risks, as highlighted in the transcript and various articles [^9^] [^11^] [^16^] [^17^].

💡Derivative Works

In the context of the SD3 licensing controversy, 'derivative works' refers to any models or creations that are based on or trained using outputs from SD3. The license terms have been interpreted to mean that such derivative works may be subject to ongoing fees and could be controlled by Stability AI, as explained by Kent Keirsey, CEO of Invoke, in a YouTube video [^9^]. This interpretation has caused忧虑 within the community, as it could impede the traditional open-source collaborative model development process.

💡Enterprise License

The Enterprise License mentioned in the context of SD3 is a commercial license that allows developers to exceed the limits set by the standard license, which caps the number of images generated at 6,000 per month. Developers who require higher limits for their applications need to acquire this license, often at a cost. The specifics of the Enterprise License terms have been a subject of inquiry for developers, as noted in the articles [^9^] [^11^], but the lack of clear communication from Stability AI has led to frustration and uncertainty.

💡Open-source AI models

Open-source AI models thrive on community contributions and the ability of developers to freely use, modify, and distribute the models. However, the licensing terms of SD3 have raised questions about the future of open-source AI development, as they may restrict the traditional freedoms associated with open-source projects. This is particularly relevant to the SD3 controversy, as the community grapples with the implications of the license on their work and the broader AI ecosystem, as discussed in the articles [^9^] [^11^] [^17^].

💡Huggingface

Huggingface is a platform where AI models, including SD3, are made available for download. Despite the ban on SD3 by Civitai, the model and its resources can still be accessed on Huggingface. This platform serves as an alternative for developers seeking to download and experiment with SD3, as mentioned in the articles [^9^] [^11^].

💡Stability AI

Stability AI is the company behind the development of the SD3 model. It has faced backlash due to the restrictive licensing terms associated with SD3, leading to a temporary ban by Civitai and concerns within the AI community. The company's communication regarding the commercial licensing of SD3 has been criticized for being unclear, as noted by developers and community members in various articles [^9^] [^11^] [^17^].

💡Community Hub

A community hub, in this context, refers to platforms like Civitai that serve as central locations for AI model sharing and collaboration. The ban on SD3 by Civitai, a significant community hub, has had ripple effects across the AI community, affecting the availability and use of SD3 models and resources, as discussed in the provided transcript and articles [^9^] [^11^].

Highlights

CivitaI has temporarily banned Stable Diffusion 3 due to licensing concerns.

The ban is due to a lack of clarity in the license associated with Stable Diffusion 3.

All SD3-based models and derivatives are affected by the ban.

CivitaI is seeking official clarification from Stability AI on the licensing terms.

The licensing terms have been considered vague and need further review.

CivitaI is taking a cautious approach by having a legal team review the license.

The ban includes models trained on content created with SD3 outputs.

Existing SD3 models will be archived and made inaccessible.

The decision is for the protection of the community and creators.

There is speculation that the ban is related to the recent release of Stable Diffusion 3 and Medium 2B.

CivitaI is not the only site requiring a license to use Stable Diffusion.

The license may grant the AI too much power over the use of SD3 images.

There has been some discussion and response from Stability AI on Discord.

Continued effort to experiment with SD3 is encouraged despite the restrictive licenses.

The outputs from SD3 can be of high quality, especially in portraits and environments.

CivitaI's decision to ban SD3 is a significant move in the AI art community.

Users can still access Stable Diffusion 3 from Hugging Face and host models elsewhere.